{"$schema":"https://json-schema.org/draft/2020-12/schema","$id":"https://assignee.net/schemas/quality-dimensions-v1","title":"Assignee Research Quality Dimensions","type":"object","required":["schema","schema_version","contract_version","dimensions","interpretation","limitations"],"properties":{"schema":{"const":"https://assignee.net/schemas/quality-dimensions-v1"},"schema_version":{"type":"string"},"contract_version":{"type":"string"},"generated_from":{"type":"string"},"dimensions":{"type":"object","required":["evidence_strength","citation_grounding","numerical_consistency","benchmark_validity","novelty","uncertainty_disclosure","reproducibility_status","safety_impact"],"properties":{"evidence_strength":{"type":"object","required":["score","level","basis","definition"],"properties":{"score":{"type":["number","null"],"minimum":0,"maximum":10},"level":{"enum":["UNASSESSED","LOW","MEDIUM","HIGH"]},"basis":{"type":"string"},"definition":{"const":"How directly and sufficiently the cited sources support the main claims."}}},"citation_grounding":{"type":"object","required":["score","level","basis","definition"],"properties":{"score":{"type":["number","null"],"minimum":0,"maximum":10},"level":{"enum":["UNASSESSED","LOW","MEDIUM","HIGH"]},"basis":{"type":"string"},"definition":{"const":"Whether claims are tied to inspectable source material and citations."}}},"numerical_consistency":{"type":"object","required":["score","level","basis","definition"],"properties":{"score":{"type":["number","null"],"minimum":0,"maximum":10},"level":{"enum":["UNASSESSED","LOW","MEDIUM","HIGH"]},"basis":{"type":"string"},"definition":{"const":"Whether reported numbers, units, ranges, and comparisons are internally consistent."}}},"benchmark_validity":{"type":"object","required":["score","level","basis","definition"],"properties":{"score":{"type":["number","null"],"minimum":0,"maximum":10},"level":{"enum":["UNASSESSED","LOW","MEDIUM","HIGH"]},"basis":{"type":"string"},"definition":{"const":"Whether benchmark references preserve task, dataset, metric, and protocol context."}}},"novelty":{"type":"object","required":["score","level","basis","definition"],"properties":{"score":{"type":["number","null"],"minimum":0,"maximum":10},"level":{"enum":["UNASSESSED","LOW","MEDIUM","HIGH"]},"basis":{"type":"string"},"definition":{"const":"Whether the work adds a distinct synthesis, comparison, or finding beyond restating sources."}}},"uncertainty_disclosure":{"type":"object","required":["score","level","basis","definition"],"properties":{"score":{"type":["number","null"],"minimum":0,"maximum":10},"level":{"enum":["UNASSESSED","LOW","MEDIUM","HIGH"]},"basis":{"type":"string"},"definition":{"const":"Whether limitations, ambiguity, and non-validated claims are explicitly marked."}}},"reproducibility_status":{"type":"object","required":["score","level","basis","definition"],"properties":{"score":{"type":["number","null"],"minimum":0,"maximum":10},"level":{"enum":["UNASSESSED","LOW","MEDIUM","HIGH"]},"basis":{"type":"string"},"definition":{"const":"Whether public artifacts and cited sources support independent inspection."}}},"safety_impact":{"type":"object","required":["score","level","basis","definition"],"properties":{"score":{"type":["number","null"],"minimum":0,"maximum":10},"level":{"enum":["UNASSESSED","LOW","MEDIUM","HIGH"]},"basis":{"type":"string"},"definition":{"const":"Whether potential misuse, deployment, or societal impact is identified when relevant."}}}}},"interpretation":{"type":"string"},"limitations":{"type":"array","items":{"type":"string"}}},"x-dimensions":[{"key":"evidence_strength","definition":"How directly and sufficiently the cited sources support the main claims."},{"key":"citation_grounding","definition":"Whether claims are tied to inspectable source material and citations."},{"key":"numerical_consistency","definition":"Whether reported numbers, units, ranges, and comparisons are internally consistent."},{"key":"benchmark_validity","definition":"Whether benchmark references preserve task, dataset, metric, and protocol context."},{"key":"novelty","definition":"Whether the work adds a distinct synthesis, comparison, or finding beyond restating sources."},{"key":"uncertainty_disclosure","definition":"Whether limitations, ambiguity, and non-validated claims are explicitly marked."},{"key":"reproducibility_status","definition":"Whether public artifacts and cited sources support independent inspection."},{"key":"safety_impact","definition":"Whether potential misuse, deployment, or societal impact is identified when relevant."}]}